May 11, 2022
Design, Technology & Society
Utopia
Question
Michel Foucault argues that every society has spaces that allow for the inversion of the general rules and morality of a society, but he distinguishes these places from utopian places. What is the difference between a utopia and a heterotopia? Are heterotopias more or less powerful than utopias in creating alternative forms of living? Have you experienced these (or similar) counter-sites? And if so, what is your experience of entering and exiting them?
Utopia is an unreal place, a "desired" reality that does not exist—an imaginary place and society. In contrast, a heterotopia is a real place that has more meanings or purposes than immediately meet the eye. Both Utopia and Heterotopia are placed outside the society which created them, though they still maintain a connection with all the places inside that society. A heterotopia is a physical representation or approximation of a utopia, or I would argue, of a dystopia (considering the example of prisons). According to Foucault, a reflection in a mirror is a utopia, a "placeless place," while the mirror itself is a heterotopia as it is real and has relationships with reality and the environment. As the utopian concept is controversial in itself—since there could be many different utopias depending on the opinions and views of different groups—I think heterotopias are more powerful as they can create a place close to Utopia for different groups. For example, a church, but this would be closer to utopia only for Christians. One of the places I would call heterotopic was an exhibition in Kunsthaus by Kader Attia called "Remembering the Future". In it, he addresses the much-debated topical issue of the ‘restitution’ of non-Western, especially African artifacts. It includes the voices of historians, philosophers, activists, psychoanalysts, and economists. In the end, there is a feeling of fully immersing into his culture and following decades of its transformation, while physically being in Zurich. I believe for him there is also a sacred meaning in all the artifacts he presented, and, as a viewer, I was able to feel the same reverence. What is interesting is the feeling of falling out of another reality while exiting the exhibition.
I see a lot of differences between heterotopias and third places. For example, in heterotopias, in many cases, people are obliged to be there. There are no prerequisites or requirements that would prevent acceptance or participation in a third place, but it is quite the opposite for heterotopias. I would consider talking clubs as a third place, where each week people gather to discuss an interesting topic, or come together with some solutions.